A TV ad recently alerted me to Comedy Central’s practice of charging subscribers $2.99 to hear the “unbleeped” versions of BOONDOCKS, one of their animated sitcoms featuring perceptive and profane children (the network’s other most prominent such program is, of course, South Park).It made me think that George Carlin might be profoundly sad, were he still alive, that after all his work to defuse the shock from the obscenity, bleeping is still in existence at all.
The ad, and the service it promotes also prompt the long overdue question; does anyone out there really find such an expense necessary anymore?
British butlers are educated from childhood to respect and exceed traditional, nay, historical, standards of erudition, sophistication, and class; but even one of these icons of aristocratic attitudes would still easily be able to tell you that, when Samuel L. Jackson, in the FX transmission of Tarentino’s JACKIE BROWN, says the compound word “melon farmer,” his character is, in fact, not referring to agricultural practitioners, or their agricultural activity or any of the fruits thereof.
Pat Robertson is so pious, bible-literate-AND-literal, that he has, after working really hard at it, distanced himself from even the most religious non-nutjob American Christians (His blaming of 911 on the gay community seemed to be the camel’s-back-breaker for most people), and one can’t ever imagine him using anything but the most courteous and refined, if heavily drawled, speech…in public, anyway. But do you really imagine that when the crudely animated young Colorado resident Eric Cartman emits the bleeped squeal, “—damn it, Kyle, you Ass—-!,” Mr. Robertson isn’t cognizant that both a holy name and the one of the most private of human orifices have both been invoked with considerable disrespect?
And whatever you’re making, I’ll confidently bet you a year’s salary that even a divine-to-semi-divine guy like Pope Benedict has a working knowledge, especially these days, that the censored print-term “cock%$&!@*” does not refer to someone who is trying to slowly consume a rooster in an oral fashion.
So why are we still going through the motions? Why do we still pretend, as a people, that we don’t know what’s under the bleep, and why won’t we admit we’re no longer really shocked?
When the FCC pursues obscenity charges against CBS for the Janet Jackson “Nipplegate” Super Bowl, and ABC for Cher’s potty-mouth at the Emmys… are they really trying to tell us that these networks are criminally liable for the unpredictable and unscripted behavior of spoiled and irresponsible celebrities? Is a pop star saying a questionable word any sort of surprise to any reasonable being?
And please notice that the FCC, which only reacts to certain specified words, or exposed skin, doesn’t rile-up at all when CBS plops TWO AND A HALF MEN into the first hour of its lineup on any given night (A time period that used to be the federally mandated family hour). Does the network do this because Les Moonvees, or one of his minions, has decided that when Charlie Sheen tells his brother that “a 22 year-old girl is like a good carpenter, no wood gets wasted,” the average 10-to-15 year-old boy (or girl!) won’t know that erections are the topic du jour? Are they telling us that because the dialogue isn’t bleeped, it isn’t dirty?
Comedy Central also bleeps Jon Stewart and Stephan Colbert in their tandem weekday faux-newscasts, but they do it with what could be either incredible ineptitude or deliberate subversive intent; a viewer can hear Stewart’s “ou” while the “Fuck y“ is safely obscured. And Colbert’s obscured “Sh” manages to sneak into the audio-sphere, even if its companion “it” is never heard.
When was the last time that a broadcast word GENUINELY offended and/or surprised you?
And the most compelling proof that we are living in the first days of a post-bleep culture is the astonishing fan-and-critic reception to the revamped BATTLESTAR GALACTICA and its similarly revamped version of the f-word, “frak.” Never before in the history of science-fiction television, has a program successfully invented and used a euphemism that sounded and felt like the word it was replacing, although many have tried with cringe-inducing results (Remember the word for “shit” on the original BATTLESTAR in the seventies? It was “felderkarp,” and I believe I’ve made my point.) The actors on the 2nd BSG always delivered the word with either the casualness or sincerity or venom that the situation required, and its impossible for those who really enjoy the series to even realize while they’re watching that an obscenity hasn’t been uttered: BSG has eerily managed to make “frak” pack exactly the same punch.
So why, really, does anyone bother with this whole obscenity charade anymore?!!
It will be interesting to see if Comedy Central actually makes money with their “unbleeping” venture.
If the “bleeping” situation suggests that we as a culture get upset about the wrong things, two commercials I’ve recently noticed confirm that suggestion as a fact.
The first spot, which I believe is about a year old, is actually two conceptually identical spots from the American Egg Board, and they are sometimes shown in tandem. The free-runner and stuntwoman Luci Romberg introduces the concept by showing us her various skills. She then sits in an egg-shaped rotating chair and declares how eggs have helped her to achieve her various goals. Just after she spins the chair so that her face and body are obscured, a gigantic hand, obviously belonging to some sadistic, homicidal giant from another reality, grabs the chair-egg containing Ms. Romberg and cracks it open causing the yellow and white mess which seems to be the rather surprising contents of the athlete’s circulatory system to spill forth and be cooked! This unthinkably sadistic spectacle is repeated in the other spot with a teenager (!), Luke Meyers, who is described in the press as a “speed stacker” because his hands move unbelievably swiftly, and he can, duh, stacks things fast. Well, this young harbinger of a potential new evolutionary ability for mankind gets similarly scrambled, and no youth or women’s organizations are on record with complaints.
And that’s not even the creepy one! The most horrifying concept being passed to the American Public as acceptable commercial content is in the Tarentino-esque Teleflora spot that recently aired in anticipation of Mother’s Day. In it, a mother and father open a box of flowers sent by their sons, and the flowers, demonstrating that “a box of flowers sometimes says the wrong thing,” start speaking anthropomorphically in the voices of said moronic sons. Sick of the banality, stupidity and downright insincerity of the foliage containing the spirits of her offspring, she sticks them down the garbage disposal as they scream in horror, one of them shrieking, “Oh, my stamen!!!!!!!!!!!!!”
Do you suppose that whoever conceptualized and scripted this spot had a happy or perky childhood? Or parenthood? Is showing casual mutilation of even mere totems suggesting the personal essence of family members truly in the best interest of America’s nuclear unit?
I remember the good old days of unintentionally offensive commercials. Occasionally, Fred Flintstone and Barney Rubble would unwind backstage (!) at Bedrock by smoking Winstons. The Frito Bandito would remind all chip-consuming children that Mexicans weren’t complete without their gold-teeth, sombrero, and snappy song. If you were a child in grade school, you learned about Native Americans from films provided to your classroom by Old Gold cigarettes, which showed buckskin clad citizens of all ages and tribes merrily puffing their way across the reservation. And of course, if you were a person of color in 1960 who objected to under-representation of your racial/ethnic group in national programming and advertising, you were in for a LONG wait. But casually grinding and otherwise mutilating the liquids, bone and various viscera of America’s youth was not even yet on the menu… so to speak.
Those who believe that we are, in fact, worried about the right things, and that obscenity in ten-year-olds trumps racial insensitivity and public visualization of barbarism will no doubt continue to attack their obvious targets… but count me among those who think that, if we are truly determined to get upset about something, we need to spread our nets wider and react to these creatively new and ingenious stimuli… rather than just become upset by rote one more infinite time over those same tired old words that George Carlin proved to be so harmless so many, many years ago.